Happy Urban Legend
A facebook friend posted a commentary at three am. The entire piece would spoil the rythym of this post, so you can read it here. Authorship was credited to a man named Ben Stein. At some point in the affair, Mr. Stein says “Next confession: I am a Jew”.
Evidently, Mr. Stein was not happy about the “war on Christmas”. Every year, about this time, people huff and puff about the way people greet each other between Thanksgiving and Christmas. The “Merry Christmas” sayers are offended that everyone does not same the same words.
It used to be the holiday season was a time of celebration. If you wanted to go crazy about the christian legends, you could. If you wanted to shop until you drop, you were encouraged. If you wanted to eat, drink, and be merry, that was fine too. In fact, the original meaning of merry was drunk.
PG doesn’t mind people saying Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, or Super Solstice. It depends on what kind of soup you are offering. It should be meant as a friendly greeting, an expression of peace on earth, and good will to men. If saying Merry Christmas means that your way of celebrating is better than mine, that leaves out the good will.
Mr. Stein, whoever he is, is entitled to his opinions. What is fun to watch here is the way people embellish the original commentary. Before long, “Billy Graham’s daughter” is running her PK mouth about what G-d was telling us after Hurricane Katrina. It was very similar to what she said about nine eleven. It has been viralized before, and probably will be again. (spell check suggestions: vitalized, liberalized, visualized, trivialized, federalized) These viral things never seem to go away.
PG made a comment about the FB post, and went out. Soon, there was another comment. “Sometimes it doesn’t matter when something was originally written or who modified it afterward, after all this is not court room testimony. This is especially true if the message has meaning. I guess if you can re-release a statement based on current events, and the statement remains applicable, then the statement is relevant. Wouldn’t we all like to say or write timeless dialog. Thanks for sharing it.”
Pictures are from The Library of Congress. This is written like H. P. Lovecraft.
Turkey Talk
Ben Franklin thought the turkey should be america’s national bird. It is identified with Thanksgiving, the holiday in November before Christmas. Mr. Franklin would not recognize the old bird today.
Turkeys have a tough life these days. Raised in factories where the lights are on 24/7, their beaks and claws are routinely broken off early on. For more details, read this piece in the New York Times, or a tasteful blog, What Would Jesus Eat.
PETA sometimes goes too far, and sometimes violates good taste. The commercial here was rejected by NBC. It uses the cliche of the little girl praying to call attention to the sorry state of the turkey. While annoying and easy to dismiss, the commercial does tell a tale.
PG should fess up at this point, and admit that he is a party to these horrors. A full blown carnivore (except for vienna sausages, which are gross), PG has no room to talk about the horrors of industrial meat production. It is Babylon…the government borrows trillions of dollars from the Chinese to pay for a war in Iraq, a book assembled by a Catholic Committee is called “The word of G-d”, and meat producing animals are raised in squalor.
A person, who is sometimes called a turkey, gave a press conference last year. The photo op was in front of a device that mutilates turkeys, and the meat processing continued while she talked. “At least this is fun”. This is a repost.
Eight More Years
BHO is the third POTUS in a row to be reelected. He is also the fourth out of the last five. If BHO serves his full second term, he will do something that has only been done once before in American history.
Between 1801 and 1825, America had three Presidents: Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe. All three were elected twice, and served a full eight years. However, two of these three had different Vice Presidents during their tenure. Thomas Jefferson had Aaron Burr and George Clinton. (The decision to replace Mr. Burr came before his dispute with Alexander Hamilton had fatal results.) James Madison had George Clinton and Elbridge Gerry. (Gerrymandering is enthusiastically practiced to this day.) Only James Monroe was a one VP man, with Daniel D. Thompkins.
If the Obama-Biden team can hold on until October 28, 2014, then another milestone will have been reached. April 4,1841, William Henry Harrison was the first POTUS to die in office. This was 51 years, and 339 days, after the inauguration of George Washington. If the cigarettes don’t kill him, BHO should break this record.
Starting in 1840 with Mr. Harrison, the zero factor saw the death, in office, of every President elected in a year ending in zero. This would affect both of the records mentioned in this post. The zero factor was beaten by Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush. Mr. Reagan’s Vice President, George H.W. Bush, is the first Vice President elected to office, without becoming President, since Martin Van Buren, in 1836. Daddy Bush lost his effort to be reelected in 1992. HT to Andrew Sullivan.
Why WMR Lost
Former POTUS wannabe Willard Mitt Romney had a conference call with some of the people who gave megabucks to his campaign. “Mitt Romney … and attributed his rival’s victory to “the gifts” the administration had given to blacks, Hispanics and young voters during Obama’s first term. Obama, Romney argued, had been “very generous” to blacks, Hispanics and young voters. He cited as motivating factors to young voters the administration’s plan for partial forgiveness of college loan interest and the extension of health coverage for students on their parents’ insurance plans well into their 20s. Free contraception coverage under Obama’s healthcare plan, he added, gave an extra incentive to college-age women to back the president.”
This is wrong on a number of levels. To begin with, why is he having this call to the people who tried to buy the election for him? This was the problem with the meeting where he made the infamous 47 percent comment. The influence of big money donors is way too great in our elections. Campaign finance reform is long overdue. BHO probably had a similar chat with his backers, but made sure not to say anything quote worthy.
The comment about free contraception is weird. If he is opposed to abortion, then this is one way to cut down on unwanted pregnancies. When it comes to women, the repubs seem to have terminal clumsiness. Of course, having more sexually active women is going to appeal to straight male voters. This can compliment the gifts BHO gave the LGBT population.
PG lives in a red state. His electoral votes were surrendered to WMR early on. Any vote PG made, in the Presidential election, was a protest. In recent years, the only time PG gets to vote on POTUS is the Georgia primary. This year, that meant making a strategic vote for a rival of WMR. It was disgusting, and ultimately WMR won the nomination.
Moving into the November race, PG felt a strong sense that WMR is a jerk. The video at the top of the text is an early indication. After a while, it seems like every time WMR opened his mouth, PG felt anger and disgust.
This has nothing to do with any opinions about BHO. The President has done a few things right, and a few things wrong. He could have done more things right if the repubs in congress had worked with him. BHO is arguably a war criminal. BHO is going to upset people in the next four years. Still, BHO is much more likable than WMR.
A lot of the so called conservative base is going to loudly agree with WMR. There is going to be badmouthing of BHO, and whining about the media. This is the crowd that WMR pandered to during the primaries. They helped him to lose.
November 11
Veteran’s Day is a bad day for a cynic. On the one hand, I do appreciate living in The United States. With all its flaws, I have had a good life here. The role that Veterans have played is to be honored. On the other hand, those who profit from wars often exploit Veterans for political mojo. Many of these people did not serve.
Veterans are often not treated well after they are through with their service. It is estimated that a quarter of the homeless are veterans. The services offered to wounded veterans returning from War is often lacking.
When I typed the second sentence, I thought of my great grandfather. He served with the Georgia State Troops in the War Between the States. I do prefer the USA to the CSA (or whatever would have happened). Yet, the Union army had to prevail over the various Confederate Armies for this to happen. Do I dishonor my great grandfather by saying I am happy the other side won?
Veterans Day was originally Armistice Day. This was the day, 90 years ago, when the War to End All Wars ended. World War I was a ghastly bloodbath, in which Millions died. It created many of the problems that plague us today. And I would be willing to bet that not one person in ten thousand today knows what it was about. And yet, the men who fought in that conflict (I don’t think they had women soldiers then) deserve the same gratitude as those who fought in any other conflict.
The soldier…many of whom were drafted…doesn’t get to choose which war to fight in. The sacrifice of the World War II soldier was just as great as the Vietnam fighter, but the appreciation given was much greater. I grew up during Vietnam, and saw the national mood go from patriotic fight to dismayed resistance. By the time I was old enough to get drafted, the Paris accords had been signed. For better or worse, there went my chance. This is a repost.
Veterans day was originally Armistice Day. On November 11, 1918, at 11 am (the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month) a cease fire went into effect for “The great war”. Officials of the major armies agreed to the ceasefire at 5 am (European time). There were an estimated 11,000 casualties in the last six hours of the war.
At 11:59 am, U.S. army private Henry Gunther became the last soldier to die in World War I. “According to the Globe and Mail this is the story of the last soldier killed in WW1: On Nov.11, 1918, U.S. army private Henry Gunther stood up during a lull in the machine gun fire and charged the enemy. “The Germans stared in disbelief,” says the Daily Express. “They had been told that morning that the fighting was about to stop; in a few minutes they would stop firing and go home. So why was this American charging at them with his bayonet drawn? They shouted at him to stp and frantically tried to wave him back but… he hadn’t heard anything of the ceasefire.” A German gunner released a five-round burst and the soldier lay dead, at 10:59 a.m. In his recently published Eleventh Month, Eleventh Day, Eleventh Hour, U.S. Military Historian Joseph Persico notes that Private Gunther had previously been a sergeant but was demoted after an Army censor read his letter to a friend back home, urging him to steer clear of the war at all costs. Gunther, who was in no-man’s land when the ceasefire news arrived, had been trying to prove himself worthy of his original rank.”
Pictures are from The Library of Congress.
Paula Broadwell Tweets
The Petraeus Affair (pun intended) is a gold mine for conspiracy fans. He reportedly was caught because his gf, Paula Broadwell, and a gmail account. Her twitter profile reads “@paulabroadwell Author (All In: The Education of Gen David Petraeus); National Security Analyst; Army Vet; Women’s Rights Activist; Runner/Skier/Surfer; Wife; Mom!” There is a New York Times article about her high octane ways. The twitter account, @paulabroadwell, is downright fascinating. This list has been edited. Pictures are from The Library of Congress.
5 Nov @paulabroadwell My take: Petraeus ldrshp maxims in Newsweek http://tinyurl.com/byeqtsx Take performance personally/if u r ok 2 b average, so 2 will be your team.
16 Oct Paula @paulabroadwell Thanks for the follow, @AlexTelman! Pls do eliminate negative energies! POSITIVITY, and a good attitude, are the keys!
14 Sep @paulabroadwell An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind. – Gandhi
13 Sep @paulabroadwell “The more you lose yourself in something bigger than yourself, the more energy you will have.” Norman Vincent Peale
7 Aug @lancearmstrong Challenging everyone to a run AND a ride in Philly Aug 18-19. Who’s with me? http://bit.ly/O0jPnl #LSCPhilly Retweeted by Paula Broadwell
7 Aug @paulabroadwell @DRUDGE_REPORT Your speculation about @petraeus as a Romney VP pic is full of non-truths (but I guess you figured that out)! @rajivwashpost
7 Aug @WomenOfHistory To be old & wise, you must first have to be young & stupid.
Retweeted by Paula Broadwell
2 Aug @paulabroadwell Mentors are critical to our development. Here are some great tips on finding and keeping them! http://tinyurl.com/c5upwzn Have any tips 2 share?
2 Aug @paulabroadwell Honored and humbled to be included in @claudiachan’s profiles of global “remarkable women!” http://tinyurl.com/bqj6yqo Thanks, Claudia!
2 Aug @paulabroadwell Networking tip for today: Pay it forward!
29 Jul @paulabroadwell Thanks for the follow, @QuoteBuddy! “A philosophy of life: I’m an adventurer, looking for treasure.” Paulo Coelho (author). You?
28 Jul @paulabroadwell Don’t wish it were easier, wish you were better. -Jim Rohn
28 Jul @paulabroadwell Txs for supporting wounded warriors and @teamrwb, @lancearmstrong! Txs for not killing me on the Aspen altitude run! All In/Keep striving!
28 Jul @lancearmstrong Back 2 @AspenCO. Just ran w/ @paulabroadwell – Author of All In: The Education of Gen David Petraeus. Talkin Petraeus, @teamrwb, and @wwpinc
Retweeted by Paula Broadwell
25 Jul @paulabroadwell “In the realm of ideas, evrythng depends on enthsiasm; in the real world, all rests on perseverance.” Fired up 2 get smkd, @lancearmstrong!
18 Jul @paulabroadwell Txs 4 hilighting female Marine perspective last week, @CNNAshleigh. Wish u’d interview women w/positive views on serving in the infantry!
30 Jun Paula Broadwell Paula Broadwell @paulabroadwell Thrilled to be heading to the #aspenideasfestival this weekend! (Now I just need some fresh ideas!)
13 Jun @paulabroadwell Txs 4 the follow, @snowlaw! A leader is a man who has the ability to get other people to do what they don’t want to do and like it.” Truman
13 Jun @paulabroadwell “Reason and calm judgment, the qualities specially belonging to a leader.”
14 May @paulabroadwell The greatest discovery of all time is that a person can change her future by merely changing her attitude. ~ Oprah Winfrey
10 May Paula Broadwell Paula Broadwell @paulabroadwell “However beautiful the strategy, you should occasionally look at the results.” – Winston Churchill
7 May @paulabroadwell Thanks for the follow, @duncanbrodie! Here’s a Petraeus quote for you: “My style of leadership depends on whom is being lead.” Thoughts?
The Fall Of P4
PG always suspected David Petraeus of being a media creation. He did have a talent for dealing with the press. With at least one “embedded” reporter, this caused him problems.
The news of his resignation is a gold mine for conspiracy fans. Usually, the press announcement of an affair comes before the resignation. The feeling here is that few would have cared about the Golden General going “All In”. Lets take a look at a few things.
Kessler: FBI Investigation Led to Petraeus Resignation. It seems as though Paula Broadwell, the gf, was improperly accessing some emails intended for Gen. Petraeus. Why was the FBI investigating the CIA? Is there some intergovernmental conflict here? Was the FBI trying to make BHO look bad? Is there so little crime in America that the FBI has time to investigate the CIA?
As for the President, he is starting his second term. Presidents who win reelection to an eight year tenure ALWAYS have problems in the second term. This goes back to Abraham Lincoln, whose second term problems were fatal.
Lets get back to the CIA. It is well known that the agency was heavily involved in the Benghazi unpleasantness. “The Wall Street Journal cites several anonymous officials who go after Petraeus hard. The CIA, operating out of an “annex” near the 13-acre consular compound, dwarfed the regular diplomatic presence in Benghazi, with the mission of hunting down ex-dictator Moammar Gadhafi’s unsecured rockets and missiles. That apparently led to an expectation at the State Department that the CIA would secure the compound in the event of a disaster, which never congealed into a formal arrangement. … And while the Journal piece doesn’t mention it, there’s a possible policy element to the discrepancy between the State Department and CIA. The CIA had 10 people to protect its annex in Benghazi, but the State Department relied on a previously obscure British firm, Blue Mountain, to guard the entire compound. Blue Mountain paid its Libyan guards $4 an hour. It’s speculative, but the State Department’s expectation that the CIA would be “the cavalry” in an assault … might have contributed to State’s relatively lax security posture at the consulate. “
The wired feature has more on the inflated reputation of David Petraeus. “Petraeus is not used to being under the bus. His record commanding the surge in Iraq has given him a tremendous reputation, within official Washington and beyond. Politicians and the press tend to downplay his missteps, such as his less-than-impressive record training Iraqi security forces and the stalemate that persists in Afghanistan despite Petraeus’ year in command.”
The Iraq “surge” was a key element in the legend of David Petraeus. Part of the surge strategy was happy talk in the US media about how we were now winning the war. It was like the old Vietnam joke … lets declare victory and go home. Only in Iraq, it was semi-official strategy. While talking about this miraculous victory, the credit went to the media saavy David Petraeus. Eventually, it fed on itself.
One of the reporters “embedded” with Gen. Petraeus overseas was Paula Broadwell. She went on to write a Glowing Book, All In: The Education of General David Petraeus. “Afforded extensive access by General Petraeus, his mentors, his subordinates, and his longtime friends, Broadwell embedded with the general, his headquarters staff, and his soldiers on the front lines of fighting and at the strategic command in Afghanistan to chronicle the experiences of this American general as they were brought to bear in the terrible crucible of war.” At some point, she became his gf. You can’t make this stuff up.
One question is why the attack on Benghazi took place? It is well known that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hates BHO, and wanted WMR to win. Could Bibi have connections in the terror underground? Was the attack on Benghazi intended to make BHO look bad? For that matter, what about the attack on an American drone by Iran? Could Bibi have influenced a rogue officer in Iran to fire on that aircraft, trying to create an October surprise? It is not Israel’s fault that the repubs were too inept to make use of such election time dynamite. Or that the people had heard so much nonsense from Fox news that they assumed the Benghazi talk was more of the same.
Pictures are from The Library of Congress. Spell check suggestion for Petraeus:Perpetrates.
Flag Lapel Pin Upside Down
As you may notice, this blog sometimes puts up collections of quotes. There is usually a document on the desktop, which serves as a recycling bin. This document also serves as a writing station for comments. The idea is to write the comment out, include all the salient links, before you enter your tidbit of wisdom. Often, a moment of discretion will occur, and the comment will not be posted. Comments never die, at least at Chamblee54. Today, we will have a collection of recent thoughts, some of which are smarter than others.
A typical night in Brookhaven sees PG editing pictures, while listening to “something”. When literally hundreds of regular podcasts, PG can only follow so many. One favorite is Bloggingheads.tv. The viewer at BHTV allows you to make a video clip. This device was invented by Greg Dingle, and is sometimes known as a Dinglelink. It is not known if this is connected to Dingleberries. This device allows the listener to illustrate a comment, with a quote from the discussion. PG even wrote a poem … Imagine a world without David Corn, ~ in which he had never been born, ~ Bob said without any scorn, ~ without a beard that is shorn.
This blog post is interrupted to listen to radio. Every Friday morning, porcine radio whiner Mike Gallagher has Chris Wallace on the show. Today, Mike is heartbroken over the election, asking if it is appropriate to wear his american flag lapel pin upside down as a sign of distress. When Mr. Wallace talks about problems with Hispanic voters, Mr. Gallagher says the Hispanics need to reach out to the republicans, not the other way around.
Getting back to dinglelinks, there is one that stands out. Last summer, certain Atlanta communities were having a group hissy fit about racism and white privilege. While this was going on, Glenn Loury said that African Americans were an extremely privileged people. PG nearly fell out of his chair.
Here is the rest of the collection. Some are calling the POTUS wannabe Money Boo Boo. ~ The Buford/Clairmont Kroger has perhaps the worst parking lot ITP ~ An unnamed source says that Fox News is going to be renamed Wolf News Network, in honor of the little boy who cried wolf. ~ After one hour and fifty seconds of chatter, there was a kumbayah moment. The contestants today kept saying “read the transcript”. Has BHTV started to provide transcripts? This would certainly benefit lazy bloggers who like to discuss your show. ~ Without any effort at coordination, here are the three loose dinglelinks that remain. tongue for truth ~ stupidity of wmr strategy ~ good person.
1- This show , with Dr. and Mr. Loury, was great fun to listen to. There were a few sound recording shortcomings, and Mr. Loury could have been better photographed. 2- Religion is a highly individual affair. Dr. Loury chose to attend a church, and it makes him feel good. I have had the church experience shoved in my face, and it made me unhappy. 3- Mr. Loury made a very insightful comment about politicians co opting a narrative politicians co opting a narrative to get elected. I don’t know whether all politicians do this, but the vast majority do. Certainly the chameleon ex Governor of Massachusetts is borrowing a different narrative every day. 4- Dr. Loury has some great comments about the “black identity” that BHO has assumed. Yes, this is the experience of the descendents of slavery, which BHO is emphatically not. (Did the ancestors of Ann Dunham own slaves?) 5- Dr. Loury had a long list of things that Jeremiah Wright is not. I cannot make a clip for everything. I found myself saying, though, that he might not be this or that, but that the public personality that I have seen is one of an asshole. You should not force white people to listen to that style of preaching and react with anything other than disgust. 6- No discussion of religion is complete without the baby and the bathwater. 7- If you disagree with the basic beliefs of a religion, you are unlikely to change your mind because they condemn your sexuality.
1- Another thing to consider is that a lot of things get posted, and sometimes some people miss a few. I honestly don’t have a clue what this discussion is about. I am not sure that I want to know. 2- Many of the race oriented discussions get very heated. There is a lot of people typing first, and maybe thinking later. You take a real chance when you comment in one of these discussions. Life is short, and I am not sure I want to spend part of mine being attacked on facebook. 3- There is an element of supremicism in anti racism. There seems to be a bully element, of people whipping up on others because they don’t like their attitudes about race.
The Chris Stevens who was killed was a diplomat. ~ “And so then I told her, I ain’t eat none of that pork or fish or whatever– all I trust is chicken and Jesus!” ~ Is there anyone who doesn’t want to march, but would like to find a spot to sit down and watch the parade? There is going to be a faerie viewing area in front of the Fox Theater during the parade tomorrow. All are welcome to join, especially those that bring snacks. ~ “A mathematician is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat, which isn’t there.” – Charles Darwin ~ The phrase I heard was “you throw like a girl”. There is an active/passive duality in throwing and catching. ~ E-Mail Filter effective immediately: Dear friends: In order to avoid repeating the last four years of discussion and anxiety please be aware that we have added another filter to our e-mails: Filter name: OBAMA contains OBAMA begins with OBAMA ends with OBAMA Send to: SPAM
After the knee jerk joke in the first comment, I felt obligated to read your feature. It seems that atheism is more closely related to Jesus Worship Religion than many realize. They are both belief based systems. You replace one set of beliefs with another. You seek validation through the conversion of others. I have my experience with the belief/disbelief cycle. To me, the goal is to live a compassionate life, and block out as much noise as possible. Sometimes my body chemistry looks for a reason to be unhappy, and Jesus is always there to remember. I don’t know what the answer is. I have written about this many times at my blog, chamblee54. I find that often when I write about these issues, I feel more unhappy than before I started. At least I can put some pictures up. The theme of chamblee54 is pretty pictures and ugly opinions. At least expressing these opinions in a written form allows the target to skip over the text. It also allows me to finish my sentence without being interrupted. Perhaps the number one problem with Jesus worshipers is the eagerness to interrupt and say things that please themselves. This is another function of the belief paradigm.
To whom it may concern, You are hereby notified that you are strictly prohibited from disclosing, copying, distributing, disseminating, or taking any other action against me with regard to this profile and the contents herein, including, but not limited to my photos, and/or the comments made about my photos or any other “picture” art posted on my profile. The foregoing prohibitions also apply to your employee, agent, student or any personnel under your direction or control. The contents of this profile are private and legally privileged and confidential information, and the violation of my personal privacy is punishable by law. UCC 1-103 1-308 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED WITHOUT PREJUDICE!
For the record, the name is pronounced BAH decker.(spell check suggestion:pecker) Just remember Bah Humbug. ~ I made a comment, regarding this comment. A man says, referring to abortion, that all life is precious. “How can you say all life is precious, but make an exception for someone in Iran, because you say the dictator wants a nuclear weapon.” “Wanhope” replied… “All life is precious … except when the life in question is being lived in a nation that does (or seems to) threaten America. It is then still precious, but must go away. ” ~ This was written like David Foster Wallace. Mr. Wallace should not be used as a role model. Pictures are from The Library of Congress.
Wolf News Network
There were two discussions recently on BloggingheadsTV which say a great deal about why the recent election turned out the way it did. The first was October 29, with Robert Wright and Ann Althouse. The second was November 2, with Robert Farley and Matthew Duss.
The original headline (the verbatim version is lost) to the Farley-Duss chat was “Why are conservatives hating on Nate Silver”? When a statistician calls the election for BHO, and the repubs scream about the messenger, that tells the observant listener that BHO is going to win.
One of the subjects discussed by Farley-Duss is Benghazi. There was an incident at the US embassy there, and four Americans died. It seems that the Wall Street Journal had a report (behind a paywall) saying that the C.I.A. had been responsible for the security. Apparently, there was confusion, and mistakes were made. However, to try to turn this into an election issue was not appropriate.
The attack on the embassy was a major theme for Ann Althouse. One eye opener was when she said that only Fox news was covering the story. When PG heard that, his first instinct was to consider it a lie. For the last five years, no anti BHO story has been too far fetched for Fox. Maybe the network should be renamed Wolf, featuring the little boy crying.
The talk about Benghazi went on for nearly ten minutes. Ms. Althouse asked how the two SEALS managed to kill sixty attackers. This is a nifty bit of rhetoric. You make a questionable claim, assume it is true, and ask how it happened. As it turns out, there is more than a little bit of confusion about what happened at the embassy.
After a while, Ms. Althouse compared the embassy attack to Watergate. This seems like a stretch, just like so much of the drivel to come out about BHO from Wolf news.
Christian Privilege
There is a lot of chatter about privilege these days. Where people used to talk about racism, today the buzzword is privilege. Chamblee54 has tried to contribute to the dialog (polylog) with recent posts about black privilege and white privilege. This is a repost.
One day recently, PG was exercising his vehicular privilege. The thought occured to him about another form of privilege. This privilege is stronger than race based privilege. In fact, many of the people, who whine about white privilege, benefit from this privilege. The president of privilege in America is Christian Privilege. (CP)
If you ask Mr. Google about CP, you get 3.6 million results. The first few give us plenty of text for this feature. A report about CP from About.com Agnosticism / Atheism has the traditional list of examples. The last few paragraphs tell more about the story.
A nonconscious ideology is analogous to the water fish swim in: fish don’t think of the water as wet because this environment is all they know — it structures their experience of life itself. Water simply is. Members of privileged groups don’t have to think about their environment because, for them, that environment simply is. They don’t have to be concerned about others’ opinions because it’s safe to assume that most think like them.
Those who don’t benefit from such an environment do have to think about it all the time because they are so susceptible to being harmed by it. For members of less privileged groups, what others think matters a great deal because their opinions and actions control access to the larger benefits of society. Fish don’t have to think about the water; mammals must remain conscious of it at all times lest they drown.
In most of the examples here, we can replace Christian/religion with male/gender or white/race and come up with the same results: examples of how our social, political, and cultural environment reinforce the dominance of one group over others. Male privilege and white privilege are closely related to Christian privilege because they have all been undermined by modernity and have all become part of America’s Culture Wars.
Christians realize that many of the above privileges are in decline. They interpret this as persecution because privilege is all they have ever known. The same is true when men complain about the decline of male privilege and whites complain about the decline of white privilege. The defense of privilege is a defense of dominance and discrimination, but for those who benefit it’s a defense of their traditional way of life. They need to become conscious of their privileges and realize that in a free society, such privileges are inappropriate.
A blog called Shakesville weighs in with On “Real” Christians and Christian Privilege . It tells the story of being asked not to identify Ann Coulter as a Christian. PG totally understands being embarassed by Ms. Coulter. There was a radio show once, with Ann Coulter promoting a book and PG listening. Some famous person was mentioned, and Ms. Coulter started to make jokes about what would happen to this famous person when he died. The line was that when he gets to heaven, he is going to wish he had been a Christian. This assumption that your ideas about life after death are correct, and universally practiced, is one especially vile example of CP.
The feature at Shakesville (which is easier to pronounce than Shakespearessister) is about how many people deflect complaints about bad behavior by saying “He is not really a Christian”. This is unsatisfactory on a number of levels. Many of the “good” Christians support “bad” Christians in their evil work. This excuse is one reason why PG prefers to say Jesus Worshiper to describe the members of this tribe. Shakes addresses this issue: “Frankly, it’s hurtful to me when Christians address what happened to me by saying, “Those aren’t real Christians,” expecting me to salve their discomfort about the baggage of privilege by not disagreeing. People who would never in a million years think to try to console a victim of a hate crime with “All [white/straight/cis/abled] people aren’t like that!” nonetheless responded that way to me when I was targeted and threatened by droves of self-identified Christians.”
Shakes is a good writer. She says things much better than this slack blogger. Maybe we should just let her explain a few things.
Christianity has a 2,000-year history that has seen countless iterations of the religion based on countless interpretation of the text and shaped to fit countless times and spaces and needs in disparate cultures all around the world. Christians have done great things, and not-so-great things—and anyone who makes the personal choice to carry the Christian mantle associates themselves with a history that includes all the good stuff and all the shitty stuff, too. One can’t say, “I only associate with the good Christianity—not the inquisitions and the genocides and the warmongering and the colonialism and the institutional misogyny, homophobia, transphobia, racism, anti-Semitism…”
That’s all part of Christianity’s legacy, too—and it just isn’t intellectually honest to say, “Well, those weren’t real Christians.” Yes, they were. And so are the Christians who do shitty stuff today. They might not be the same kind of Christian as you are, but they are nonetheless Christians.
Christianity, at least (and especially) in America, is a privilege—and, like any privilege, it can be uncomfortable to face the ugly reality of what other members of a privileged class can do to non-privileged folks, even if you don’t do it yourself. I’m white, I’m straight, I’m cisgender: I understand the impulse to distance oneself. But as a white person, I am obliged to acknowledge that the history of white supremacy in America is one of slavery, of lynchings, of segregation, of sundown towns, of internment camps, of genocide, and of all manner of institutionalized racism. I don’t get to say (nor do I want to) that the KKK aren’t “real” white people. They sure as hell are.
That Christianity is a chosen privilege does not mean its members can claim a lower standard of rigorous self-examination. And it doesn’t mean that less privileged Christians, i.e. progressive Christians, can claim a lower standard, either, just because the more privileged Christians marginalize them. Poor whites don’t get to disclaim their white privilege just because they are further marginalized by their lack of wealth.
In fact, chosen privileges demand, if anything, a higher standard of self-examination, because one has a choice whether to participate in the privilege. But so often, the fact that Christianity is a choice is instead used to deny the effects of that privilege altogether—”I’m not one of those Christians; I’m one of the good ones!”
Letter To Seventy Eight Year Old PG
There was a suggestion at WordPress to write a letter to yourself as a fourteen year old, and another letter to yourself in twenty years. PG thought this was a cool idea. If the trackback went up on the WordPress site, then it might generate some traffic for this blog. It might even get the attention of Freshly Pressed , which has never featured Chamblee54.
It is like General Halftrack and the Pentagon. The Daily Post did not post a link to friday’s letter. The traffic went below one hundred hits on saturday. Now it is sunday, the clocks are set back an hour, and it is trying to rain. The letter to a seventy eight year old PG is a good idea, so here it goes. Once again, it is in first person. Pictures are from The Library of Congress
Ok, so you are twenty years older. Or maybe you are not. The three main older people in this life were Mom, Dad, and Gran. They all died when they were seventy five, except for Mom, who made it to seventy six. Seventy eight might be pushing things a bit, considering the way things sometimes feel at fifty eight. The idea is to write this letter, and not worry about whether the destination will have an internet connection.
This is the sunday before the Presidential election, aka the day when a dictatorship doesn’t sound so bad. People in Georgia have their votes stolen from them by the electoral college, so we don’t have to choose between a war criminal and a liar. Or is this choice between a liar and a war criminal wannabe?
There is a saying about holding your nose when you vote. The neighborhood precinct is the cafetorium of a school. Unless you are blocking the memory, you might recall going to classes in that building. Tuesday will not be the first time I have held my nose in that cafetorium.
This is the first year of the City of Brookhaven. I find myself choosing people on the basis of personalities, rather than issues. When it comes to the so called issues, the candidates seem to say the same things. This is true for the State House race, which is the other choice I will have. The repub is just plain gross. Mr. Bahhumbug has a bright future if he doesn’t get caught again.
There is no telling what the election choices will be in 2032. Assuming that the electoral college continues to facilitate the two party duopoly, you probably won’t have much of a choice. The takeover by the moneylenders should be complete by that point.
Since we are doing this in twenty year cycles, lets look back to some other elections. The first time I got to vote was 1972. Tricky Dick was a thief, and a war criminal, but George McGovern was a dummy. The problem for Tricky Dick was the second term syndrome. Most Presidents who are reelected for a second full term have horrible problems. While Mr. Nixon’s second term was not as bad as those of Abraham Lincoln or William McKinley, he did have his problems.
In 1992, it looked like Daddy Bush was sailing to victory. He won a war, and the Democratic candidate was Slick Willie Clinton. (From Tricky Dick to Slick Willie, Bebe Rebozo to Monica Lewinsky.) Ross Perot threw a monkey wrench in the electoral works by running as a third party candidate. This is a feature of the duopoly… when one party wins the Presidency too many times, something strange happens.
It happened in 1912, when Theodore Roosevelt ran as a third party candidate, and Woodrow Wilson got elected. Within a year, the Federal Reserve Bank was set up. After the re-election of Mr. Wilson, we got mixed up in World War One. There is nothing good to say about the elections of 1932 and 1952.
There is one more election that should be discussed here, even though it is not part of the twenty year cycle. I was listening to a chat before the 2000 election. One person thought it was important to vote for Al Gore. This had been a dull election. George W. Bush was sort of an unknown quality, while Al Gore was not a terribly inspiring figure.
That is not how things turned out. W was allowed to serve, after Mr. Gore won the popular vote. Seven months after the inauguration, 911 kick started the twenty first century. The response of W was to start two self destructive wars. With the help of the demoze, there was a tax cut before the start of the second war. The economy may never recover.
So, it is good form to write a last paragraph to these things. It is an act of optimism to assume you will be here in twenty years. Living in the WMD age, the idea of thermonuclear catastrophe has always been present. The possibility of man making the planet unlivable is also very real. Maybe a dependable source of non destructive energy will be found in the next twenty years, to go with a dependable source of water for Atlanta. The future has always been dim, but somehow it continues to happen.
Horse Hight Pig Tight Bull Strong
There was a link at Peach Pundit yesterday, Lee Anderson Website Issue Quiz! It is supposed to be off the website of Lee Anderson, who is running for Congress in the redneck triangle. PG couldn’t find it, but is confident that it is somewhere.
The quiz has four questions. There is a saying, and the idea is to find a current issue to go with the phrase. This ought to be a good excuse to spin out some text to go between the pictures. These images are from The Library of Congress. The answers are below the questions, and looking ahead is considered cheating. Anyone cheating on a meaningless internet quiz has got problems.
Question 1. There is an old saying, “G-d gives every bird a worm, but he doesn’t throw it in the nest.”
Tax Policy ~ Abortion ~ Wildlife Management ~ Job Creators ~ I’ve never heard anyone say this.
This is sort of a strange quote. Rumors of a pundit named Jerome Old turn out to not be true. If you ask Mr. Google, he says it is a Swedish folk saying, or that P.D. James said it. There is also a quote by Ogden Nash. “I am a conscientious man, when I throw rocks at seabirds I leave no tern unstoned.” If marijuana regulation were on the Georgia ballot, then this might be germane.
That site says the Question 1 phrase is a “Swedish Saying”. It has a quote by Anonymous: “Test-tube babies shouldn’t throw stones.” There is a quote from Brink Lindsey: “But in the terrible, simplifying clarity of war, it is apparent who is on one side and who is on the other. In the struggle between civilization and barbarism, those who throw rocks through McDonald’s and those who ram airplanes into buildings are expending their destructive energies in a common cause.”
Question 2. On the farm, keeping what you want in and what you don’t want out is important. Your fences need to be horse-high, pig-tight and bull-strong in order to do their job.
Birth Control ~ Wildlife Management ~ Illegal Immigration ~ Job Creators ~ Illegal Aliens are essentially livestock, no wait, the aliens are to like vermin or something, so our citizens are the livestock, and they shouldn’t be able to leave. Right? No?
Did someone say horse high? They might be talking about Latawnya, the Naughty Horse, Learns to Say “No” to Drugs. “This is the tale of three African American horses (Latawnya, Latoya and Daisy), who leave the stable and get drugs from four white horses (Connie, Chrystal, Jackie and Angie). It is a timely and poignant tale that will leave you laughing, crying, and making scary noises. It starkly and accurately presents the real dangers horses in black neighborhoods face from Caucasian equine drug pushers; when one of the horses died of a drug overdose, this reviewer wept openly. This is a lesson all children, foals, calves, chicks and cubs must learn before it is too late. A classic of our time. “
Question 3.Mark Twain once said that politicians are like diapers: they must be changed often and for the same reason. [Hint, he goes on to say: “In my view, 8-12 years is enough for anyone, and I will work to make term limits in Congress a reality.”]
Birth Control ~ Term Limits ~ Tax Policy ~ Diapers should probably be changed more often than politicians ~ We should vote out Barrow in Four Years?
Term limits is one of those things. When the Contract on America was foisted upon the Clintonized landscape of America, term limits was part of the deal. The fact that Newt Gingrich had been in Congress for sixteen years was not considered important.
Question 4. A teacher once told me that as long as the federal government is involved in education, it will always be mediocre for the same reason that in large kitchens, the cooking is usually bad.
Immigration Policy ~ Tax Policy ~ Federal Education Policy ~ Support of the Federal Cafeteria Awareness Act ~ Lee Anderson hates restaurants.
This does not indicate what subject the teacher taught. If he/she was a science teacher, this might be worth listening to. If he/she was a math teacher, then this doesn’t add up. If he/she taught English as a Second Language, then most Chinese restaurants have small kitchens.
1. Either Tax Policy or Job Creators would be correct. Lee Anderson thinks there is too much regulation and that’s like weeds in a garden. He then trumpets his rating from the National Federation of Independent Businesses, which endorsed John Barrow, so maybe he got a higher rating?
2. Illegal Immigration. Great line here: “Somehow the greatest country on earth, who put a man on the moon, can’t build a fence along the border with Mexico?”
3. Term Limits. And Mark Twain didn’t say this.
4. This is part of what appears to be a long diatribe about Emeril Legasse not accepting American culture, but if you said Federal Education Policy, I suppose you can count it as correct. But seriously, what is so bad about restaurants? Are they not job creators? If you eat at home, aren’t you costing American jobs?































































































































































leave a comment