Chamblee54

Matthew Is Too Republican

Posted in Uncategorized by chamblee54 on January 4, 2010


Today is the first Monday after the New Year. A day to get back to what occupies us for most of the year. It is also the 11 day of Christmas, with 11 pipers piping, and the end of the NFL regular season. The Falcons had back to back winning seasons.

PG found a story about the Christmas season at another blog a few minutes ago. It is a feel good tale, even if you don’t completely agree with it. Much has been made recently about the “true meaning” of Christmas. This story says that Christmas is about being good.

Some atheists put up a sign, encouraging people to “be good for goodness sake”. While this is a *good idea*, it is also a line from a silly Christmas carol. It was written because it rhymes with “he knows when you’re awake”. Maybe we should just leave it as a silly rhyme in a song, and not make a rule for living out of it.

As we said, PG does not totally agree with this story (written in first person). Or maybe he wants to argue about the words, but agrees with the spirit behind the words. Sometime the spirit is what is important.

PG is a practice kind of guy. Belief is all well and good, but what is do is what is important. A gram of practice is worth a pound of belief.

I just said goodnight to Granny and turned off the lights in her room. After getting her settled in, I sat next to her on top of the covers. We propped ourselves against the headboard and watched TV for a while.

She got tired but wanted to hear the story of the nativity before she fell asleep. As you all know, I’m not the most religious person in the world, but I’d have to be a downright heathen to refuse to do that. So, I grabbed Granny’s Bible off the night table and read from the second chapter of the Luke. No room at the inn. Shepherds and their flocks and all. But no Wise Men. No kings.

At first I thought maybe I was reading from one of those contemporary editions or something. But when I looked at spine, it said “King James.” I asked Granny about it and she told me, “That’s Matthew.”

Then she told me she prefers Luke, which is why I guess that’s what she asked me to read. I asked her why she preferred Luke since it was essentially the same story. “Luke is more for regular folk. Matthew is too…too…” She searched for the right word, then finally finished her thought with, “too Republican.”

We both chuckled about that and I made a mental note to tell the Attorney, who has been known to have Republican tendencies.

Apparently there are differences in the facts of the Christmas story, depending on who told it. Luke talks about the manger and shepherds. Matthew talks about the kings. The shepherds heard from an angel. The Wise Men followed a star. Isn’t it kinda ironic that the Gospels are not necessarily the gospel?

So, I guess it shouldn’t be a surprise that even now, 2000 or so years later, that Christmas is a different thing to different people. But whether your Christmas includes shepherds…or not. Kings…or not…Jesus, Santa, Angels, Rudolph, presents, trees, or stars…or not, we’re all celebrating the same thing. The easy answer is “the birth of Christ.” But the bigger answer is “goodness.”

You may not believe a baby was born in a manger to a virgin. Or, if you do, you may not believe that babe is the Messiah. But, if you celebrate Christmas at all, surely you can believe in the goodness that the story represents. And, if you don’t celebrate, surely you can believe in goodness nonetheless.

It’s all mankind truly has to give. Happy Holidays, dear friends and readers.

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Tony's avatar Tony said, on January 5, 2010 at 1:21 am

    It seems like PG may not agree with the approach, but with the result, maybe?

  2. Matthew Is Too Republican | Chamblee54 said, on January 4, 2015 at 2:11 pm

    […] following story is a repost. Pictures are from The Library of Congress. Today is the first sunday of the new year. Yesterday saw […]


Leave a reply to Tony Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.